Best Car Insurance for a Bad Driving Record (2025)

The Highlights

• Your driving record has the biggest impact on your car insurance rates.
• Car insurance for drivers with points on their driving record will be much higher.
• Most tickets and accidents will come off of your driving record in three to five years.

If you have a bad driving record, your auto insurance rates will be much higher than normal. How much higher will depend on a lot of factors, like the type of tickets you’ve received, if you have an at-fault collision, or if you have any DUIs or other driving violations. Drivers who have poor driving habits are considered high-risk. Usually, bad driving will result in more claims, leading companies to charge higher rates or a yearly rate increase.

There are some ways to keep your bad driver insurance rates as low as possible. One way is to shop around and compare car insurance quotes. Each auto insurance company will charge different rates, so it’s helpful to get multiple quotes to find the best car insurance for a suspended license or otherwise poor driving record. Enter your ZIP code now to start comparing cheap car insurance quotes for high-risk drivers if you have a bad driving record.

Can you get bad driving record car insurance?

Usually, car insurance companies don’t penalize a driver too badly for a mistake every now and then. However, when accident claims and/or driving violations pile up, coverage rates will skyrocket because car insurance companies consider those with multiple traffic violations high-risk drivers.

Read more: How long do accidents stay on your Car Insurance record?

Depending on your situation, it can be difficult to find the best auto insurance after a DUI, ticket, or at-fault accident. Not only is it hard to find coverage, but it will also cost you much more than if you have a clean driving record. Let’s take a look at just how much a ticket, at-fault accident, or DUI can affect your car insurance rates.

Average Annual Car Insurance Rates Based on Driving History

While a speeding ticket will only raise your rates about $45 a month, a DUI will raise your rates around $150 a month. If you have multiple infractions, your rates will be extremely high.

According to the above table, what is the best car insurance for drivers with bad records? American Family, Progressive, and State Farm have the cheapest rates that can be offered to anyone. USAA also has low rates for drivers with a bad driving record, but they only offer coverage to the military and their families.

It’s fairly easy to improve your driving record as long as you pay attention, don’t drink and drive, and obey traffic laws. Doing so will ultimately bring your car insurance rates down.

Even if you have tickets or accidents on your record right now, they will generally come off in three to five years. That means your rates will go down as well, provided you don’t add any other infractions.

How to Find Cheap Car Insurance for Bad Driving Records

Bad driving record auto insurance at an affordable price can be hard to find. If your driving record is bad enough, your state can make you get special insurance for high-risk drivers.

What is high-risk auto insurance called? High-risk insurance is usually called non-standard insurance. Although some major companies will offer this coverage, many smaller companies, like Titan Car Insurance, will specialize in this type of insurance. Sometimes you can find cheaper rates with a company that mainly offers non-standard insurance.

It’s not uncommon for a state to suspend the license of a particularly bad driver.

If that happens, the driver can usually request a special license that only allows them to drive in certain circumstances, like for work. This is called a hardship license.

What insurance companies will insure a suspended license? You will not be able to get insurance until your license is reinstated in some form. Some companies will offer SR22 coverage. An SR22 is a form that your auto insurance company provides your state saying that you have auto insurance coverage. This type of coverage can be required if your license has been suspended or if you have DUIs.

Read more:

• Best Car Insurance for Drivers with a Suspended License
• Titan Insurance Review & Complaints: Auto Insurance

Unfortunately, it’s not possible to find auto insurance that doesn’t check driving records. All insurance companies will check your record, but they won’t all charge you the same rates. Affordable auto insurance with a bad driving record isn’t easy to find, but it’s possible.

It’s important to note that the cost of auto insurance will vary from state to state and company to company. For example, high-risk auto insurance in Florida for a bad driving record will have different costs and requirements than in California.

What about auto insurance that doesn’t check driving records? Unfortunately, that doesn’t exist. Even though a poor driving record makes car insurance more expensive, you have to be honest with your auto insurance company.

According to the Insurance Information Institute, lying on your insurance application can be considered fraud. You can buy auto insurance with a bad driving record from most companies, but some may deny you coverage. With a bad driving record, auto insurance companies need to consider the risk.

If you have a bad driving record and need car insurance, we can help. Since every company is different, compare auto insurance quotes regularly to get the best deals. Enter your ZIP code now to start shopping for car insurance with a bad driving record.

Case Studies: Unveiling the Best Car Insurance Solutions for Drivers With Bad Records

Case Study 1: Don Insurance Company – Tailored Coverage for High-Risk Drivers

John is a 35-year-old driver with a bad driving record. He has multiple speeding tickets and an at-fault accident on his record for the past two years. John is actively seeking car insurance but is concerned about high premiums due to his driving history.

John researches various insurance companies and discovers Don Insurance Company, known for providing tailored coverage for high-risk drivers. He contacts their customer service and explains his situation. Don Insurance Company conducts a detailed assessment of John’s driving record and takes into account other factors such as his age, vehicle type, and location.

After analyzing John’s information, Don Insurance Company offers him a comprehensive coverage plan specifically designed for high-risk drivers. Despite his bad driving record, the premiums are relatively affordable compared to other insurance providers.

Additionally, Don Insurance Company offers optional driver improvement courses to help John enhance his driving skills and potentially lower his premiums over time.

Case Study 2: Core Auto Insurance – Progressive Premium Reduction Program

Sarah, a 28-year-old driver, has a bad driving record with two at-fault accidents and a DUI conviction. She wants to find car insurance that offers competitive rates and supports her efforts to improve her driving habits.

Sarah comes across Core Auto Insurance, a company that provides a unique Progressive Premium Reduction Program. Intrigued, she contacts their customer service and shares her concerns about her bad driving record. The representative explains that ABC Auto Insurance offers a program where premiums decrease over time based on safe driving behavior.

Sarah decides to enroll in the Progressive Premium Reduction Program offered by Core Auto Insurance. As part of the program, she installs a telematics device in her vehicle to monitor her driving habits.

By practicing safe driving, adhering to traffic rules, and maintaining a clean record, Sarah gradually starts to see a reduction in her insurance premiums. This program not only incentivizes safe driving but also helps Sarah financially by gradually decreasing her insurance costs.

Case Study 3: Friends Insurance Company – Accident Forgiveness and Customer Loyalty Rewards

Mike, a 45-year-old driver, has a bad driving record with multiple accidents and traffic violations. He is searching for an insurance company that provides coverage for drivers with a history of accidents and also offers additional benefits. Mike discovers Friends Insurance Company, which specializes in assisting drivers with bad driving records.

He contacts their customer service and expresses his concerns. The representative explains that DEF Insurance Company offers accident forgiveness, which means Mike’s premium won’t increase after his first at-fault accident. Furthermore, they have a customer loyalty program that rewards policyholders for maintaining a clean driving record and staying with the company.

Impressed with the benefits offered by Friends Insurance Company, Mike decides to switch to their coverage. Shortly after enrolling, Mike experiences another at-fault accident. However, due to the accident forgiveness policy, his premium remains unaffected.

Over time, Mike maintains a clean driving record and receives loyalty rewards from Friends Insurance Company, including discounts on future premiums and additional coverage benefits. This encourages Mike to continuously improve his driving habits and stay loyal to the insurance company.